Paul married Catherine Margaret Bunker on 15 Aug 1945 in Menasha, Winnebago, Wisconsin, United States, and was divorced. Catherine (daughter of Jeremiah (Jerry) Bunker and Mary Louise Gauthier) was born on 7 Apr 1922 in Neenah, Winnebago, Wisconsin, United States; died on 21 Apr 2000 in Waterford, Racine, Wisconsin, United States; was buried in Apr 2000 in Waterford, Racine, Wisconsin, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Michael Allen Butterfield was born on 14 Aug 1945; and died.
2. Mark Robert Butterfield
3. Scott Andrew Butterfield was born on 20 Sep 1947 in Wisconsin, United States; died on 31 Jan 2011 in Hot Springs National Park, Garland, Arkansas, United States.
4. Mary Elizabeth Butterfield
5. Kathleen Ann Butterfield
6. Linda Jean Butterfield
7. Janet Louise Butterfield